On Campus / Viewpoint Diversity

The Academic Journal Article that Made 16,000 Ideologues Go Wild

By Peter Wood ● Minding the Campus ● 10/04/2017


Portland State University scholar Bruce Gilley drew a lot of attention with his August 29 article on Minding the Campus, “Why I’m leaving the Political Science Association.” A week or so later, he provoked an even greater controversy by telling readers of the Third World Quarterly what they don’t want to hear.

“The Case for Colonialism” was by ordinary academic standards a straightforward opinion essay: well-reasoned, well-informed, and cognizant of conflicting views. It had passed peer review and the judgment of the journal’s editor. A contemporary scholar arguing the case in favor of a positive judgment of the history of Western colonialism, however, was clearly venturing into territory that carried the risk of adverse reaction among his peers. It wasn’t long before that reaction arrived.

Other Articles In This Category:


New York Times ● By Dan Levin

“I’m Not the Only Young Conservative”

The Cardinal Newman Society ● By R. Jared Staudt

Education and the Formation of Culture

James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal ● By Chris West

Free College Is Just Another Middle-Class Entitlement

VIEW MORE